Ms. Feminist goes to Strippertown

So putting aside my terrible attempt at a pun in the title there (sorry, I’ve had that title planned for a week), I have a rather amusing tale for all you feisty feminists/humanists to ponder tonight: my trip to the local strip club.  Yes I, Ms. SuperFeminist (who would make a totally awesome superhero by the way), accompanied my male friend to a strip club downtown in order to celebrate his 21st birthday in the classical fashion: watching women get naked and objectify themselves while men throw dollar bills at their… umm.. yeah.  Highlights included sitting at the front and basically watching my friend get a lap dance for every strip (it also helped that it was about 6 PM and no one else was in the club), observing what I like to the call the “2nd shift” of women come in to work and release a Pandora’s box of sadness onto the stage (one girl seemingly avoided looking into the crowd and barely danced… I think she was about to cry), getting into the club free on the premise that I was cuter than my friend (those stripper pimps really know how to compliment!), and even visiting one happy and somewhat well-adjusted stripper’s house after the birthday festivities were over.  Actually, the last one was pretty significant, as it gave me a more positive view of the whole business than I might have had coming in.

In fact, the stripper case study fits pretty well with my “thesis” for today about feminism: that we ought to support women in all their chosen endeavors, whether it be working in Doctors Without Borders, becoming stay-at-home moms of 16 children, or even selling their sexualities in the form of seemingly physically impossible pole-dancing tricks (seriously, how do they do that?).  But I’m sure at least some of you are saying, “But Sasha, objectification of women goes totally against the goals of feminism!  Stripping, prostitution, and pornography all degrade women by reducing them from human beings to simple sex objects!”  Now this is a pretty common feminist argument, but I just don’t buy it.  You see, once upon a time when feminism was just getting started, we proclaimed the movement to be about one thing and one thing only: obtaining more rights and opportunities for women.  Look, even Wikipedia agrees with me.  But anyhow, some of those rights included the freedom to express one’s sexuality as well as the freedom to make decisions about one’s body in general (fine, this was in 2nd-wave feminism, but my point still stands).  While we often like to pretend those freedoms only referred to birth control access and the loosening of strict sexual mores that hold women to the “virgin standard”, in fact I’d say those rights meant to encompass a lot more.  If some women truly feel comfortable expressing their sexuality in the form of stripping, prostitution or doing terribly-written adult films, and I would dare say that many of the strippers I met were, I see no reason why mainstream feminists should be attacking their lifestyle decisions; such negative, judgmental attitudes go completely against the idea of women’s choice and feminism as a means of supporting the development of healthy women.  Sure, some will throw out wild claims that objectification such as that seen in stripping and prostitution is degrading and unhealthy, but I think we would have to be delusional to pretend that all objectification has such a destructive influence.  After all, plenty of women do one-night stands or friends with benefits, both of which often involve simplifying a human being to a simple sex object, and plenty of these women leave such encounters as sane and healthy as when they initiated them.  Why is it more acceptable for women to objectify or be objectified when no money is involved but morally bankrupt and anti-feminist when it is involved?  After all, money provides pleasure for women in a different way by helping them pay their rent and the occasional fun nights out.  As someone who attaches some emotional significance to sex and doesn’t enjoy the leering of creepy men, I couldn’t personally be involved in such businesses, but that doesn’t give me the right to look down upon those who are involved in them.

Of course, there are truly tragic cases in the sex-related fields.  Plenty of impoverished women are ashamed of these jobs and only do them to make ends meet, and prostitution especially has an ugly history of sexual violence.  Perhaps though this is an even bigger reason for why feminists should not stigmatize women who turn their bodies into commodities; women can only turn to us for help if they feel that they will be respected and welcomed into the community.  We achieve nothing we the “stick” approach of punishing impoverished women with negative, judgmental attitudes; we will do much better with the “carrot” approach of showing all the dreams women can achieve in they fight for equal rights, utilize all the educational and social resources available to them, and work hard to break through that glass ceiling.  Let us say: you can be anything you want to, from a prostitute to the first female president”, not “you can be anything you want to… except a prostitute”.  And on the final note of prostitution, as feminists we should push for the legalization of this business whether we find it personally offensive or not.  Why?  Because our job is to nurture the development of healthy women, and we can’t do that if the law doesn’t even protect such poor segments of female society from sexual and physical violence.  As my stripper club-attending friend and I discussed over drinks, prostitutes do not have the same legal rights and protections from harassment and violence that strippers do, and this should be unacceptable no matter your moral views on the two practices.


5 thoughts on “Ms. Feminist goes to Strippertown

  1. I completely agree with your point that women should be supported in whatever profession they choose and not be ostracized, or stigmatized, or any kind of “ized” at all for a personal decision. I think it is something we all need to work on whether we realize it or not. When one of my good friends tells me she wants to have five kids when she is older and that she has their names picked out already, my inward reaction is usually less than excited. If I can be supportive outwardly, I’d really like to be able to make myself supportive in a sincere manner too!

  2. I agree with all of this too, but I would like to point out what makes prostitution so unsavory to me. It’s not the women who WANT to strip or have sex or anything else for money (they should feel free to do so, be it for pleasure or out of sheer necessity), it’s the women who DON’T want to. Prostitution rings that trap girls and women – and potentially men, too – into years of abusive and degrading service are a real problem, and I think that any sort of legalization of prostitution would have to be handled very carefully to keep these sorts of systems outlawed. I like to think that this would be easier to do if prostitution were legal, but the legislation would have to be airtight (which is apparently uncommon) in order to eliminate any loopholes pimps/gangs/whoever could jump through.

  3. That is true regarding prostitution… I’ve seen so much where people are unsure of how much female agency plays a part. But statistically, most women enter prostitution between 14-17 and they do so because they have been horribly abused in the past. Trafficking and prostitution are much, much larger problems and despite what kind of factor agency plays, I think the majority, not all, but most, of prostitutes really have no other means of survival… which kind of points back to capitalism which is a whole other problem too!

  4. I feel kind of sad when I see prostitution and stripping lumped into the same category. I mean, it’s all in the same order – all Carnivorae, if you will – but to me, the difference between them is like that of a cat and a raccoon. (Misplaced biology references stop here.)

    When it comes to the prostitution rings trapping girls… Yeah, that’s pretty ill. (Put mildly.) However, there’s also a huge drug war going on in Mexico right now over marijuana [among other things], and people want THAT legalized, too. We’ve yet to legalize it, so there’s no hard evidence, but it makes you wonder: how much violence and gang activity would be stopped if there were no black market for it? Most of the common thugs that pimp unwilling girls out will not pass muster if they had to form a business, pass medical inspections (for the girls, I mean), and run a clean establishment.

    While I’m not saying there aren’t loopholes – we’re humans; finding loopholes is what we do – there IS evidence of some decent success with legalization. I believe both Tyra and Oprah had wonderful show segments regarding legal prostitutes. The Oprah segment was part of an “alternative lifestyles” show, I think, which also featured the world’s only caucasian geisha. The girl they talked to seemed to lead a very healthy life and enjoyed her job, and when they toured the establishment and the medical examination rooms and everything, I was impressed. Honestly, I was vaguely envious of their superior healthcare.

    (The Tyra one was more controversial, as the girl started under 18 – legally – because her father consented. She also had two apartments and a flatscreen by age 19. Not bad, not bad. NOTE: It wasn’t prostitution – the Tyra one is stripping! Oops!)

    Either way, I suggest a quick YouTube search for both of those clips; they’re very fascinating. And it’d be interesting to hear about the trip to the stripper’s house after the birthday celebration! (In the context in which it was brought up, it sounded mildly dodgy…)

  5. I really like this blog and I think it points out some important issues in regards to prostitution, stripping, etc. I think the reason many feminists are uncomfortable with these jobs where money is exchanged for sexual favours is because, even in cases where the women are willing, well-adjusted, healthy, and actually want to do what they are doing in spite of having many other options (and by the way, these cases are in the small minority in general), there is not a lot of sexual freedom in such a job. This is where the exchange of money involved makes it different from things like one-night stands, which everyone generally finds socially acceptable.

    A prostitute like the one I described (healthy, willing, well-adjusted, happy, etc) may easily have a day where she thinks “Hey, I just don’t feel like having sex today” or “Ugh, I really don’t want to have sex with that creep there” but may have no choice but to go through with it because she can’t afford to turn away customers or not work one day because it’s the way she makes her living and needs to eat her daily bread. Similarly with stripping. So in the end, even the happiest individuals in these professions may have days when they are having sex or stripping when they don’t want to. And NO ONE should have sex if they don’t want to, or if they feel they “have” to, for whatever reason. That is denying rather than promoting sexual freedom.

    That said, I do agree with legalizing prostitution and giving social acceptance to those in the profession. It will help the circumstances and improve quality of life both for those who don’t want to be there and those who do.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s